Spread the love

I recently smoked the Key West Select Torpedo, a great cigar at an exceptional value. I have provided my full review below. This content uses referral links.

the Key West Select Torpedo

Estimated Reading Time: 4 minutes

A recent shipment from Cigar of the Month included the Key West Select Torpedo. This was an A- cigar at an A+ price. In fact, the Key West Select Torpedo is the best value cigar that I have had in a long time.  

Key West Select Torpedo

A Dominican cigar with Dominican fillers, a Sumatran binder, and an Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper, this was a smooth, sweet smoke. 

Cigar of the Month recommends pairing it with a pilsner. As is my usual habit when tasting cigars, however, I enjoyed mine with a good cup of coffee.

In my grading system and review below, I have adopted the Cigar Journal: For the Discerning Aficionado method. It provides an excellent system for keeping track of my favorite smokes, and I recommend it to any cigar smoker.

Look of the Label

As the picture indicates, the label was subdued and low key. It had an eloquent simplicity that I like.

3/3 points

Key West Select Torpedo’s Condition

The cigar came in fair condition. It looked a bit wrinkled and dry. It was, frankly, not a great looking cigar, and the wrapper split on me in the middle of the smoke.

4/7 points

Feel of the Cigar

The cigar felt well made. It was consistently packed with just the right amount of give on the squeeze. The roll was nearly perfect.

3/3 points

Aroma of the Wrapper

The pre-lit cigar smelled of cedar with hints of floral and cream. It was a bit too subdued for my liking, but it was a nice smelling cigar regardless.

2/3 points

The Cut

The cut was ok. I was able to slice off the cap quickly and easily, but the cap flaked and frayed a bit, not what you want to see.

0/1 point

Lighting the Key West Select Torpedo

The Key West Select Torpedo was stubborn and very difficult to get lit. I’m generally pretty patient when it comes to getting my cigars going, but this one took way too long and was way too much trouble.

0/1 point

The Draw

The draw was just a bit too tough for my liking. It wasn’t too bad, but the resistance was more than I like in a lighter cigar like this. It made it just a little too challenging to pull enough smoke into my mouth.

It was good, but not great.

4/5 points


On the retrohale, the Key West Select Torpedo was extremely smooth with hints of cream and an almost candy sweetness with a bit of mint. 

9/9 points

Key West Select Torpedo’s Flavor 

On the cold draw, I picked up hints of pepper but nothing else. This was a bit surprising given the scent of the wrapper, but it was nice nonetheless.

After the light, the smoke was very smooth with scents of cream and perhaps some cedar mixed in. It was a wonderfully smooth and delicious smoke.

21/21 points

Aroma of the Smoke

After the initial light, the smoke smelled of pepper yet somehow managed to maintain a smooth aroma. Still, it was nothing overly appetizing or impressive.

5/7 points

The Burn

The burn was mediocre at best. It burned evenly, but I always felt like the cigar was about to go out.

1/2 points

The Ash

The ash was fine. There was nothing impressive about it, but I never had to worry about its dropping off into my lap.

1/1 point

Effect of the Smoke

I know that this is a bit of an odd category to consider. As the author of The Cigar Journal: For the Discerning Aficionado notes, however, if the best-tasting cigar in the world makes you sick, it’s not a great cigar for you. 

This area is, therefore, very personal. Some low-quality cigars will make most people sick. Still, when you’re talking about premium cigars, different people will react differently to different cigars.

This cigar left little physiological effect. It did not leave me with that nice mellow feeling that I like, but it was enjoyable nonetheless. I have no complaints.

30/30 points

Key West Select Torpedo’s Tobacco

The Key West Select Torpedo showed itself to be well-made here. No flakes of tobacco found their way into my mouth at any point during the smoke.

7/7 points

Key West Select Torpedo Final Grade

Overall, this was a nice cigar. While it isn’t among the best cigars I’ve ever had, I’m confident in its low A grade. It was a fantastic cigar, even if it was not quite extraordinary. But, at $2.38 per stick, this is a value that just cannot be beaten. I will likely soon pick up a box for everyday smoking.

Final Grade: 90 / A-

Cigar of the Month Club   

As always, I recommend Monthly Clubs’ Cigar of the Month Club. I’ve been a member for years, and I love it. If you join, you’ll get five premium cigars delivered to your door every month for just $32.95, including shipping.   

(There’s also a slightly more expensive Rare Cigar Club available, for those who are interested.)   

The opportunity to try a variety of high-quality cigars and to learn more about cigars in general through the accompanying tasting notes has been an invaluable experience for me. I have enjoyed being a member, and I recommend giving it a try.   

If you’re interested and would like to use my referral link, I would appreciate it. Just click here. If you do, I may receive a commission at no additional cost to you.   

If you’d prefer not to use my link, however, I still recommend the Club. Just go to Monthly Clubs’ Cigar of the Month website to explore Monthly Clubs’ offerings.   

Join Cigar of the Month Club Today>>

See Also:  

Perfect Scores

A-Rated Cigars

B-Rated Cigars

C-Rated Cigars

D-Rated Cigars

Great Values


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *